?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

I went to see "Atonement."

I went to see the Kiera Knightley film "Atonement." It's drawn from an Ian McKewan book about an upper middle class family home. Two daughters (Knightley and a 13 year old I don't know) and a number of servants are amongst the people that live on the 'country estate.'

The crux of the story is that the younger child sees something she misunderstands and (as a consequence of the misunderstanding) sends Knightley's working class boyfriend to prison. The remainder of the film looks at the aftermath of that incident.

The film reminds me a little bit (at a stretch, if I squint) of what might have happened after the trials in To Kill a Mockingbird or A Passage to India, if they'd be set against the backdrop of the English class system (rather than across racial boundaries).

It was actually an ok film, but I found the particular 'social norms' of 1930s England got in the way of the film. I wanted to yell 'Ok, we get it, now move the story along" on occasions.

Thinking about it, there were a couple of other things that bugged me too. Firstly, the extremely posh and well brought up younger sister (who is 13 remember) comes across an 'expletive' in the course of what she's doing. We are expected to believe she knew the significance of a word I didn't know at 16 and kept the note as evidence for later.

Secondly, James McAvoy (the lower class lover) has an extremely posh accent for someone in his stage of life. I understand he went to Cambridge University, but his accent never changes, even when he's with his friends. I don't know about you but I always find people speak differently at home and because McAvoy didn't I found him less believable.

Tags:

Profile

jamiebowen0306
jamiebowen0306

Latest Month

January 2013
S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031